FirefighterCountry

Firefighters open chat room for serious learning and sharing without fear

DO WHAT YOU ARE TOLD WITHOUT QUESTION OR DO WHAT IS RIGHT

People,

Once again the news reports are of an accident caused from clear negligence and failure to follow basic protocol.

 

It is reported that individuals are being dismissed from their department because of an accident on a railroad crossing in Michigan involving a fire truck and a train. I ask everyone to follow this link, read the article and comment on the matter:  http://www.firerescue1.com/apparatus/articles/966367-Amtrak-sues-De...

 

I feel it is time that some changes are made with respect to the training  of apparatus operators because too many expensive pieces of equipment are being lost to sheer incompetence and the operations commanders are going without reprimand for endangering their crew, equipment and citizens at large. For me this is a "no-brainer", you just do not park on railroad crossings!

 

I understand that the pressure to respond to those in need is great and the situations can be confusing when so many departments are involved during a rescue but this to me is no reason to create another problem that may be equal to or greater that the initial call.

 

I have personally been subjected to reprimand for failing to follow direct orders from my superiors when I felt I was being ordered to create a clear and present danger to my fellow Firefighters and the equipment I was responsible for. I was told that whatever my superiors told me to do I must do without question because "that is just the way it is done" and I could not in good conscience neglect my duty to the department and citizenry by creating a threat to life and property. 

 

How do you feel about taking responsibility and doing what you were trained to do in cases such as the one in the article at the link posted on this blog? Would you do only what you are told when you clearly see that it is irresponsible?  Would you park equipment on a railroad crossing because your incident commander instructed you to?

 

I apologize to all who read this blog and feel I am unworthy of wearing the uniform of a Firefighter but I was trained as well as everyone else that safety comes FIRST so when I see an obvious danger I waste no time in reporting it to my superiors before I act but if they just dismiss my observations I will take responsibility for my crew mates safety and accept the consequences.

 

I feel too often mistakes are made because commanding officers are more interested in "being in command" than they are with being responsible and listening to their team members observations and making informed decisions that recognize the need for safety first.    

Views: 7

Comment

You need to be a member of FirefighterCountry to add comments!

Join FirefighterCountry

Comment by Lieutenant Frederick Georges on February 3, 2011 at 12:22am
I strongly feel it is my duty to obey protocol and respect my station when ordered by my commanding officers to perfect any procedure necessary unless I feel it will create a threat to the safety of my crew mates or the general public.

I see in the article linked to this blog that a police car was also parked on the railroad tracks but was able to escape in time and I have to ask.. what were these trained public servants thinking? It is a fact that police officers have reprimanded engineers for stationing their apparatus in the roadway to protect the responders from passing traffic so how is it possible this officer failed to demand the fire truck be removed from the crossing?

HIGH RISE FIREFIGHTING

 

LINKS

YOUR AD HERE

Free Search Engine Submission

Badge

Loading…

YOUR AD HERE

FIREFIGHTER UNIFORMS

GLOBE FIRE SUITES

***CUSTOM HELMETS***

FIREFIGHTER BOOTS

EDUCATION PROGRAM

CLICK ON THE LINK TO HELP PREPARE OUR NEXT GENERATION TO BE TOMORROW'S FIREFIGHTER-EMT's                               N.S.V.F.F.   

© 2018   Created by Lieutenant Frederick Georges.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service